Advertising Disclaimer: This website is supported by its audience. The content is not a news article or independent review. We compare and rank products and may include affiliate links. This comparison and ranking has been sponsored by Bettervits. For more information, see Advertising Disclosure..

Our Top 5 Probiotic Supplements in 2024

Find out which supplements actually work and which to stay away from

Advertising Disclaimer This website is supported by its audience. The content is not a news article or independent review. We compare and rank products and may include affiliate links. This comparison and ranking has been sponsored by Bettervits. For more information, see Advertising Disclosure. This website is supported by its audience. The content is not a news article or independent review but is a sponsored comparison by Bettervits.

Why Take Probiotics?

Bloating, gas, constipation or irregular bowel movements - these are just some of the consequences of poor gut health. In fact, it is becoming more understood that the majority of our well-being and health begin in the gut. Your gut houses over 70% of your immunity and when bad bacteria overload the good, this is when many start to suffer symptoms ranging from bloating to serious illnesses.

A good quality probiotic supplement can help replenish and balance your gut with healthy, productive bacteria. However, not all probiotic supplements are equal, and choosing the wrong one can be ineffective, costly and in some cases cause further damage.

How Does Probiotics Work?

From a high level, probiotic supplements work by providing a dose of good bacteria which can help restore disrupted flora in your gut. Research shows that taking anywhere from 60-80 Billion CFU per day can have immense benefits in the way your gut operates. Subsequently, a healthy gut in turn boosts your immunity, energy, metabolism and overall health.

This good bacteria helps to fight against and equalise an overload of bad bacteria, which can be caused by unhealthy foods, lack of exercise, pollution and even stress. It’s important to monitor signs of gas, bloating and other gut issues, it may be a sign that you need a probiotic.

Benefits of High Quality Probiotics

Supplements can be a very effective and inexpensive method of improving your gut health. By choosing the right supplement, you could feel a difference from just 2-3 weeks. Probiotic strains such as Lactobacilus and Bifidobacterium offer a plethora of broad and gut-specific benefits.

  • Improves Gut Issues

    Bloating, gas, flatulence and stomach cramps are all signs of bad bacteria overload in the gut. Probiotic strains such as Lactobacilus could help correct this imbalance and relieve your stomach of these issues.

  • Encourages Restful Sleep

    Studies have shown that there may be a relationship between bad bacteria in your gut and your ability to fall asleep. So probiotics could improve your sleeping habits. This is just one of the ways that probiotics have health benefits that reach far beyond your stomach.

  • Strengthens Immunity

    With over 70% of your immune system residing in your gut, its crucial to offer it the best protection and support. Probiotic supplements can replenish your gut with helpful bacteria so it can help prevent you from catching the flu and other infections.

  • Promotes Brain Health

    Research shows that when there is bad bacteria in your gut, your gut can send confusing signals via the 500 million neurons in your spinal cord. This could mean that poor gut health is leading to stress, brain fog or memory slips.

Why Are Prebiotics Just As Important?

When looking for a high quality supplement, it is very important to watch our for the number and types of strains, as well as the addition of prebiotic in the formula. Each probiotic species comes in various strains, each which contribute their own unique benefits. Meanwhile, prebiotics are the food source for the healthy bacteria.

  • The best two probiotic species are Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus. They provide the most in terms of beneficial bacteria. It is normally recommended to take in 5-6 strains of Lactobacillus and 3-4 strains of Bifidobacterium.
  • Inulin is one of the best prebiotic you can have in a probiotic supplement. It is a rich source of food for the healthy bacteria you will intake and allows them to thrive, therefore increasing the effectiveness.
  • A ‘nice to have’ ingredient in your probiotic supplement is Vitamin B12. Your gut craves B Vitamins to help create red blood cells and gain more energy from the food you consume. Combining this with probiotic helps your metabolism and helps reduce symptoms of poor gut health.

What To Look For?

Not all supplements are equal. It's important to only choose supplements that fit the following, or you may not experience an improvement and could lose your money.

  • Includes Bifidobacterium + Lactobacillus A high quality probiotic should include Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus, two of the most effective probiotic species. Countless research shows the ability of these probiotics to boost immunity and gut health. A high quality supplement should contain 8-10 strains of the above species.
  • High Dose of 70-80B CFU Quality is better than quantity, but both is even better. It’s important to ensure that your probiotic delivers sufficient CFU (colony forming units) to bring real improvements to your gut health.
  • Includes Prebiotic Inulin Without prebiotic, many supplements are prone to not being effective, simply because there is not enough food for the good bacteria to survive. Therefore it is important to ensure that your probiotic includes around 75 to 100mg of inulin.
  • Money-Back Guarantee It is important to buy from brands that stand behind their product. Without a money back guarantee, you could lose your money and end up with an ineffective product. It is recommended to look for brands that offer a 30-60 day guarantee.

What Should I Avoid?

  • Poor Formulations & Doses As stated before, not all probiotic supplements are equal. It is recommended to stay away from supplements that offer too low of a dose (<20B CFU) and similarly, too high of a dose (>90B CFU). According to the medical experts, it has been found that there is no incremental benefits in taking higher CFU doses beyond this.
  • Artificial Reviews Watch out for product listings on Amazon and other marketplaces. In many cases, these reviews are fake and only made to increase their visibility. Buy from brands that have trusted-looking websites and produce their supplements locally.

How We Assessed The Top 5 Supplements

Each of our reviews go through a strict analysis and comparison test. We study the ingredients, effectiveness and manufacturing to understand the quality of the product. Furthermore, we evaluate customer reviews, value for money and customer service to protect readers from negative buying experiences.

  • Effectiveness

  • Ingredients

  • Value for Money

  • Customer Service

A+

OVERALL GRADE

TOTAL RANKING

  • Ingredient Safety
    9.9AVG. 9.9/10
  • Projected Efectiveness
    9.8AVG. 9.8/10
  • Value
    9.7AVG. 9.7/10
  • Return Policy
    9.5AVG. 9.5/10
  • Customer Satisfaction
    9.6AVG. 9.6/10

Pros

  • Powerful 75B CFU Count
  • 14 Diverse Strains
  • Includes Vitamin B12
  • Suitable for Vegetarians and Vegans
  • Made in USA
  • Free Shipping
  • 60 Day Money-Back Guarantee

Cons

  • Only Available Online Only Available Online
  • Sometimes Out of Stock

The Bottom Line

Out of all Probiotic supplements we reviewed in-house, Bettervits Probiotics came out on top in almost every benchmark.

Firstly, they contain the most powerful dosage with 75B CFU from a mix of 14 different bacterial strains. This is an optimal dose of bacteria to ensure effective results. It includes strains from Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus families which have been extensively researched and proven to boost gut health, support immunity and help manage weight.

Another benefit of Bettervits Probiotic is you just need 1 small capsule per day. Their capsules are vegan friendly and time-delayed, allowing the bacteria to survive throughout the digestive process, resulting in better absorption and results. By including 100mg of Prebiotic Inulin, it allows the Probiotic to thrive in the gut and collectively with Vitamin B12, it is a super weapon for your gut.

Bettervits really ticks all the boxes when it comes to making a great Probiotic supplement. Despite this, it is well-priced and comes with a 60 day money back guarantee (even on open bottles), so you can try it risk free today.*

* Results and rankings are based on subjective opinion and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Please visit product website for more information.
We found one coupon code for this product: PRO10 for 10% off

2. Probiotic

by Physicians Choice

B+

OVERALL GRADE

TOTAL RANKING

  • Ingredient Safety
    9.2AVG. 9.2/10
  • Projected Efectiveness
    9.0AVG. 9.0/10
  • Value
    9.1AVG. 9.1/10
  • Return Policy
    9.5AVG. 9.5/10
  • Customer Satisfaction
    8.8AVG. 8.8/10

Pros

  • 60B CFU
  • Includes Prebiotic
  • Vegan Friendly

Cons

  • Only 10 Strains
  • Includes Sunflower Oil
  • No Money Back Guarantee

The Bottom Line

Physicians Choose is one of the most popular brands and their products are well regarded. However, their Probiotic specifically does fall short on a couple of points:

In terms of bacteria strains, it includes just 10 strains, which is not an ideal amount as we generally recommend 12+ strains for maximum diversity. The CFU dose of 60B is reasonable however and is a sufficient amount.

In addition, their capsule includes Sunflower Oil, which has been shown to release toxic compounds and may result in inflammation.

Last but not least, they include no money back guarantee, which makes it much riskier than our #1 option. The problem with supplements is that it may not always work for you, so we do recommend going with a brand that offers a real money back guarantee in case it doesn’t. *

* Results and rankings are based on subjective opinion and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Please visit product website for more information.
We found one coupon code for this product: PRO10 for 10% off

3. Probiotic

by Pure Encapsulations

C

OVERALL GRADE

TOTAL RANKING

  • Ingredient Safety
    8.7AVG. 8.7/10
  • Projected Efectiveness
    89AVG. 8.9/10
  • Value
    9.0AVG. 9.0/10
  • Return Policy
    8.2AVG. 8.2/10
  • Customer Satisfaction
    8.6AVG. 8.6/10

Pros

  • Includes Lactobacillus
  • Includes Bifidobacterium
  • Vegan Friendly
  • 1 Capsule Serving

Cons

  • Lower 50B CFU Dose
  • Only 7 Bacteria Strains
  • No Money Back Guarantee
  • Very Expensive

The Bottom Line

Pure Encapsulations is a very popular brand of supplements, and generally is known for good quality products. Their Probiotic is no different but it does fall short on a couple of important benchmarks.

Firstly, it only includes 7 bacteria strains, which means there is less diversity in the benefits that each bacteria strain delivers. Competing brands provide 10-15 bacteria strains so 7 is considered quite low.

In addition, with a dose of 50B CFU, it is not considered a strong dose relative to other options on the market. However, their product is clean and free from fillers as well as being vegan friendly.

Overall, it is a decent probiotic option but given the lower doses and the price tag, we don’t rank it well for value for money.*

* Results and rankings are based on subjective opinion and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Please visit product website for more information.
We found one coupon code for this product: PRO10 for 10% off

4. Digestive Probiotic

by Nature Made

D

OVERALL GRADE

TOTAL RANKING

  • Ingredient Safety
    8.5AVG. 8.5/10
  • Projected Efectiveness
    8.0AVG. 8.0/10
  • Value
    8.1AVG. 8.1/10
  • Return Policy
    8.0AVG. 8.0/10
  • Customer Satisfaction
    8.4AVG. 8.4/10

Pros

  • 12 Bacteria Strains
  • 1 Capsule Serving

Cons

  • Low CFU Dose
  • Only 25 Capsules Included
  • No Money Back Guarantee

The Bottom Line

Nature Made is another recognised brand in the nutrition industry. Their Probiotic includes a 30B CFU dose and 12 bacterial strains. We believe 12 strains is considered sufficient and diverse set of bacteria, however, the amount of bacteria is very low at 30B CFU.

We would recommend at least 60 or 70B CFU for a sufficient dose and to see better results.

In addition, their product is not very good value for money as they include only a 25 day supply, which is not even enough for a full month. Combined with the lack of money back guarantee, we consider this to be a riskier option than other products on the market.*

* Results and rankings are based on subjective opinion and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Please visit product website for more information.
We found one coupon code for this product: PRO10 for 10% off

5. Gut Restore

by Primal Harvest

D-

OVERALL GRADE

TOTAL RANKING

  • Ingredient Safety
    8.5AVG. 8.5/10
  • Projected Efectiveness
    7.6AVG. 7.6/10
  • Value
    7.3AVG. 7.3/10
  • Return Policy
    8.1AVG. 8.1/10
  • Customer Satisfaction
    8.2AVG. 8.2/10

Pros

  • Includes Tributeyrin
  • Vegan Friendly

Cons

  • Only 3B CFU
  • Only 1 Bacteria Strain
  • Poor Value For Money

The Bottom Line

As a relatively new entrant to the nutrition space, Primal Harvest aims to make one-stop formulas for a wide range of problems. Their Probiotic product aims to alleviate digestive issues and “restore the gut”.

However, it is not necessarily a good option for those looking purely for a high quality Probiotic and Prebiotic. It includes other ingredients such as Tributyrin, but lacks when it comes to CFU count and bacteria strains (just 3B CFU and 1 strain).

We would recommend this for readers who have not perhaps seen results from Probiotics and would like to try an alternative option.*

* Results and rankings are based on subjective opinion and do not necessarily reflect typical results from the use of these products. Please visit product website for more information.
We found one coupon code for this product: PRO10 for 10% off

2024's Top Probiotic Supplement

Overall, we highly recommend Bettervits Probiotic Complex and have chosen it as #1 based on a strict, scientific review of it's ingredients, formula, doses as well as the brand's ethics and customer satisfaction.

MADE
IN THE USA

FREE
SHIPPING

MONEY-BACK
Guarantee

Final Thoughts

Probiotics are a popular product that is used worldwide. However, as with all supplements, it's important to do your research to ensure you are only using those with the highest chance of success. We conduct in-depth reviews to help our readers avoid common pitfalls associated with supplements, allowing you to shop smart and safely.

After thorough research across hundreds of brands, it's clear that Bettervits offers an all-round 5 star product, with effective ingredients, robust formulas and a thoughtfulness for customer satisfaction. This makes it, in our opinion, the best probiotic and gut-health supplement on the market.

Lastly, Bettervits provides a 60 day money back guarantee if you're not 100% satisfied.

CLICK HERE TO TRY BETTERVITS PROBIOTIC

Disclosure

We strive to ensure that comparisons are made on the basis of factual information such as ingredients, quantity of ingredients, real customer testimonials, manufacturing location, return policies and other pertinent information to evaluate a product.

The information contained within this site is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice. If you have, expect to have, or suspect you may have any medical condition, you are urged to consult with a health care provider. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any diseases or medical conditions.

This website curates rankings and comparisons of market leading products. We may receive compensation from some of the companies whose products are featured on this website. As a result, we receive payment when you purchase a product using the links on this website. This compensation may affect how and where products appear on the site, including the order in which they appear. This site does not include and rate all products in each category and results are not typical.

Return to